When it comes to restaurants in the Keys, Islamorada stands out—and you don’t even have to cross a bridge to find some of the best spots. From locally caught seafood and fresh French pastries to fish tacos locals rave about, here are a few of our favorite places to eat around town.
Breakfast/Coffee
- Cafe Moka — A cozy spot with a full coffee menu, fresh pastries (the almond croissants are dangerously good), delicious yogurt (trust us), and savory quiches.
- Midway Cafe & Coffee Bar — Breakfast served with an island vibe. They have a great menu filled with options for everyone, and a full coffee menu to get your day started.
Lunch
- Bad Boy Burrito & Sushi — This local favorite serves up flavorful tacos (the fresh-catch fish tacos are a must), creative specials, and burritos packed with bold flavors. They also offer fresh sushi and poke bowls that are as refreshing as they are delicious, along with unique teas and juices that pair perfectly with the flavors they serve.
Dinner
- Square Grouper — A must-visit in Islamorada with something for every mood. Downstairs, enjoy a full restaurant menu with fresh, flavorful entrees. Upstairs, the lounge offers craft cocktails and a unique tapas menu, with ceviches and desserts that are always on point.
- Chef Michael’s — Specializing in perfectly cooked dishes and the freshest local fish, Chef Michael’s is a locally owned and operated gem. The care in both quality and service shows in every bite, making it a standout for fine dining in Islamorada.
Sushi
- Sushi Sake — Menu full of fresh ingredients and something for everyone. We highly recommend the wahoo tataki as an appetizer.
- Shima — You’re going to have to cross a bridge for this one, but it is worth the short drive north to Tavernier to experience the presentation, flavors, and atmosphere.
Pizza
- Bayside Gourmet — When it comes to pizza, Bayside Gourmet is always our go-to. You really can’t go wrong with any of their pies, but the saltimbocca (especially on cauliflower crust for that thin, crispy perfection) is a top contender.
If you try any of these spots, we’d love to hear what you think. And if you’re ever looking for more local recommendations, feel free to reach out! We’re always happy to talk good food.